RESPECT: A Simple Charter for Good Debate

IMG_3489When I went on Sabbatical at the beginning of July Theresa May was still Prime Minister. In the past three months a new resident occupies 10 Downing Street and has caused scandal and outrage, leading to a breakdown of trust. This is a serious matter; democracy is built on trust.

The Brexit process has become more fractious and political debate toxic. Hatred and threats of violence abound, with many MPs receiving death and rape threats. It is a truly worrying time. There is an urgent need for behaviour in our public discourse to improve. After a particularly outrageous outpouring of vitriol and hostility in Parliament a few weeks ago, I wrote a Short Charter for Good Debate. The aim was quite simply to encourage MPs and Councillors to ‘play the ball and not the player’, to honour and respect those with whom we disagree and help cohesion where there are deep divisions – we are going to have to live together in the future, as now, and what happens in this moment can help that or damage it deeply. There is a need for moderation in language; to be careful that words do not incite hostility.

Unknown to me the House of Bishops of the Church of England were preparing a statement too, though theirs seems to have had to be clarified and has been widely criticised – precisely what is meant by honouring the 2016 vote is difficult to assess, that vote being at best ambiguous in its meaning and so much water has flowed through the Brexit channel since. There have been subsequent statements from a number of bishops which seem to imply that they are not as signed up to it as the press release seemed to state.

I offer this ‘Simple Charter for Good Debate’ as a encouragement to improve public discourse and help remove the toxicity from debate, whatever side anyone takes.

RESPECT: A Simple Charter for Good Debate

Respect the person

Engage with issues

Shun hatred and all language that inflames it

Protect the vulnerable

Evidence arguments and statements

Conduct yourself with integrity

Transparency and Truth enable Trust.


About Revd Canon Ian Black

Ian is Vicar of Peterborough, Canon Residentiary of Peterborough Cathedral and Rural Dean of Peterborough. He previously served for 10 years in Leeds, as Vicar of Whitkirk and as a member of the Chapter of Ripon Cathedral. He has also worked in Kent in Maidstone and as priest-in-charge of a group of parishes 10 miles north west of Canterbury. He was a Minor Canon of Canterbury Cathedral, a prison chaplain and Assistant Director of Post-Ordination Training for the Diocese of Canterbury. Prior to ordination Ian had a career in tax, both with the Inland Revenue as a PAYE Auditor and a firm of Chartered Accountants as a Tax Accountant. Ian is married with two sons. He is the author of three books of prayers: Prayers for all occasions (SPCK 2011), Intercessions for Years A, B & C (SPCK 2009) and Intercessions for the Calendar of Saints and Holy Days (SPCK 2005). His latest book is 'Follow me: living the sayings of Jesus' (Sacristy Press 2017). He has been writing online since the mid 1990s.
This entry was posted in Blog and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.